Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mina Howell's avatar

Listening to this as I write my battle scene 😈

Thank you so much for compiling this list! It is SO helpful!

Expand full comment
Derek James Kritzberg's avatar

I loved this article.

I'd like to add my own - battles are places of extreme paradoxes. Love of comrades and hatred of enemies, the clash of horror and bravery, a duality of humanity's worst urges and greatest virtues, all these come into stark contrast in battle. An deep awareness of these dualities leads to great battle-writing.

There's one more of these paradoxes I'd like to append to the "battles are not organized" note - yes they are! But they also aren't! Medieval battles might be a great place to look at this phenomenon - these have long and protracted "organized" phases, and not just pre-battle, but at the climax of the actual fight. This is something movies regularly get wrong.

Formation was everything - your shield protected the man to your left, or your spear protected the man to your front! This reliance on organization is what made attacks on the flanks and the rear of a formation so devastating. It becomes extremely difficult to trade places with the man in front of you when there is no front! Yes, the front rotated every 5-15 attempted blows delivered/absorbed, enough to wind a very fit person wearing effective armor and wielding a proper weapon.

There might be considerable chaos in the minds of the participants, but an iron discipline throughout as well - otherwise their cause is hopeless. When a formation breaks, it's usually because that side is about to lose or already lost. Most of the killing and chaos occurs during the rout when victory has long been decided.

Small time chaos might rear its head at the "front" where all the stabbing and blocking happens. Things happen fast there! The general melee depicted in movies is quite rare in all eras - no one would know who to stab or shoot, the friendly fire would be outrageous. In reality everyone finding themselves in that situation would be running to the safety of their own lines not just by instinct, but practical common sense - be they a French Knight or a ww2 infantryman. Only senseless death and accidental killing of friends can occur in a place where all formation has collapsed. It isn't prone to happening (usually just one side collapses or the other, not both) and if it did happen the participants would soon seek their banners and reform.

The one exception is Russel Crowe who obviously recognizes the face of 100% of all his legionaries, and they all hold their blows because no one wants to accidentally stab Russel Crowe, right?

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts